← Business

Vibecession

Paris Street; Rainy Day, Gustave Caillebotte
Paris Street; Rainy Day, Gustave Caillebotte

A reader's summary of the word coined for an economy that the statistics call healthy and the public calls bad: where the term came from, the numbers that made it necessary, the competing explanations for the gap, and why the argument over it became one of the defining online economic debates of the 2020s.

The term at a glance

A vibecession is a period in which people feel that the economy is in recession, or about to be, while the conventional indicators (employment, output, incomes) say it is not. The word blends “vibe” and “recession”, and its point is that the vibe is itself an economic variable worth taking seriously. It sits next to doom spending, which describes what anxious consumers do with their money, and shrinkflation, one of the quiet price changes that feeds the mood. The way bad economic news travels faster than good is a case of negativity bias, and the feeds it travels through owe something to doomscrolling.

Origin

The word was coined by Kyla Scanlon, an economics writer and video creator, in a Substack post in June 2022. That month the University of Michigan's index of consumer sentiment fell to 50.0, its lowest reading since the survey began in the early 1950s, lower than during the 2008 financial crisis or the 1980 recession. At the same time the American unemployment rate was about 3.6 percent, close to a half-century low, and employers were struggling to fill vacancies. Scanlon's first argument was that the gloom could feed itself: people who expect a recession act in ways that make one more likely. The word stuck because it described something many readers recognized in themselves, a sense that things were bad that did not match the headline figures.

History and context

The obvious culprit in 2022 was inflation. American consumer prices rose 9.1 percent in the year to June 2022, the fastest pace in four decades, and similar spikes hit Europe after the energy shock that followed Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The puzzle sharpened in 2023 and 2024, when inflation fell back toward 3 percent, unemployment stayed under 4 percent, growth held up and the predicted recession never came, yet sentiment recovered only partly. A widely cited Guardian/Harris poll in May 2024 found that a majority of Americans believed the country was in a recession, which it was not.

Economists offered several explanations. One is the gap between the inflation rate and the price level: when inflation slows, prices stop rising quickly but do not come back down, and people compare today's prices with what they remember. Wage gains that caught up over time felt earned, while the price rises felt imposed. A second, from a 2024 working paper by Marijn Bolhuis, Judd Cramer, Karl Oskar Schulz and Lawrence Summers, is that the cost of borrowing belongs in the cost of living: once mortgage and credit rates are counted, the squeeze households felt in 2023 looks much closer to what surveys reported. A third is housing, where high prices and high rates together locked many younger people out of ownership. A fourth is partisanship, which pulls survey answers apart along party lines and flips them when the White House changes hands.

The term traveled. Commentators used it for Britain, Canada and parts of Europe, wherever strong labor markets coincided with a cost-of-living squeeze and sour moods. It also became a political argument in its own right, with one side saying the public was being misled about a good economy and the other saying economists were dismissing real hardship by calling it a vibe.

Main ideas

The data and the mood can split

Unemployment, growth and wage figures can all be healthy while surveys of how people feel about the economy sit at or near record lows. The vibecession names that gap rather than either side of it.

People remember prices, not rates

Economists celebrate when inflation falls. Households notice that prices stay high. A slower rate of increase still leaves groceries and rent well above where they were, and that level is what people feel at the till.

Borrowing is part of the cost of living

Official price indices leave out mortgage rates and consumer credit costs. When rates jump, a household buying a house or a car feels poorer even if the measured inflation rate is calm.

Mood can become an economic fact

If enough people believe a downturn is coming, they spend less, hire less and wait, which can help bring about the downturn they feared. Scanlon's first framing was exactly this self-fulfilling loop.

Sentiment is filtered through identity

Survey answers about the economy swing sharply with who holds power. Supporters of the party out of office rate the same economy far worse, so part of any vibecession is a measure of politics, not of prices.

In the feed

The vibecession was partly an online phenomenon, and the feed shaped it in two ways. First, it supplied the evidence people used. A screenshot of a $20 fast-food meal, a viral receipt or a thread about rent travels much further than a monthly jobs report, and each one is an accurate story about a price level that the aggregate statistics average away. Second, it supplied the argument. Charts showing real wages rising were posted to settle the question and were met with replies saying that the person posting did not shop for groceries. Both sides were often describing real things: the averages were good, and the households at the margin, renters, first-time buyers and people carrying credit card debt, were doing worse than the averages implied. The word gave each side a way to describe the other, which is part of why it spread.

Critique

  • “Vibe” can sound dismissive. Calling public pessimism a mood implies it is mistaken. Critics argued that high prices, high rents and expensive credit were material facts, not feelings, and that the word let analysts wave them away.
  • The averages hide the distribution. Median figures can improve while a large minority falls behind. A healthy aggregate and a bad experience for many households are compatible, so the “gap” is partly an artifact of what is being averaged.
  • Sentiment surveys measure politics too. Because answers move so strongly with party, a low reading is partly a verdict on the government, which makes it hard to read as a pure economic signal.
  • Media incentives are not the whole story. Blaming negative coverage is tempting, but studies of news tone find that economic news has long been more negative than the data, including in periods when sentiment was high. Coverage cannot explain the timing alone.
  • Feelings have consequences. Even if the gloom is overstated, it can change spending, voting and investment. Treating it as noise to be corrected misses that it is also a real input to the economy.

Impact

The vibecession pushed economists and central bankers to pay more attention to how inflation is experienced rather than only how it is measured, and it revived interest in alternative price indices that count borrowing costs. It also became a lesson for politicians: in several elections of 2024, governments that could point to low unemployment and falling inflation still lost to voters who remembered the price level. For a reader, the useful habit is to hold both kinds of evidence at once. When the statistics and the mood disagree, the question is not which one is wrong, but whose experience each one is measuring, and who is left out of the average.

How to read this page. A reader's summary for orientation, not an economic analysis. Figures, dates and attributions, especially the sentiment and inflation readings, the date and wording of Scanlon's original post and the findings of the 2024 working paper and polls, should be checked against the primary sources before being quoted.