← Philosophy

Tall Poppy Syndrome

Poppy Field, Claude Monet
Poppy Field, Claude Monet

A reader's summary of the urge to cut down whoever stands out: the tyrant's wordless advice in Herodotus and Livy, the Australian phrase of the 1930s, Scandinavia's Law of Jante, Norman Feather's research on deserved and undeserved success, and why every viral success story now seems to come with its own pile-on.

The idea at a glance

Tall poppy syndrome is the tendency to resent, criticize or try to bring down people whose success makes them stand out from their peers. It covers a range of behavior, from a sneer at a colleague's promotion to a public campaign against a famous founder. The phrase implies a fault in the people doing the cutting: it treats envy as the motive and the success as innocent. That assumption is where most of the argument about it starts.

Origin

The image comes from two ancient stories about tyrants. In Herodotus's Histories (Book 5), Periander of Corinth sends a messenger to ask Thrasybulus of Miletus how best to rule. Thrasybulus says nothing, walks the man through a field and cuts off every ear of wheat that stands above the others. Periander understands and has the leading citizens of Corinth killed. Livy (Book 1) tells the same story about Tarquinius Superbus, the last king of Rome, who strikes off the tallest poppy heads in his garden to tell his son how to handle the leading men of Gabii. Aristotle, in the Politics, cites the anecdote with the roles swapped, as an example of how tyrants keep power by removing anyone outstanding.

History and context

The modern phrase is Australian. “Tall poppies” became a common political expression in the early 1930s, attached to New South Wales Premier Jack Lang's policy of cutting the highest public-service salaries during the Depression. Over the following decades it lost its link to pay and came to describe a cultural trait that Australians and New Zealanders often say they have: an egalitarian dislike of people who seem to think too much of themselves. Similar ideas exist elsewhere. Denmark and Norway have the Law of Jante, from Aksel Sandemose's 1933 novel. Japan has the nail that gets hammered down. Several countries use the image of crabs in a bucket. Academic work followed in the late 1980s, when Norman Feather at Flinders University began measuring attitudes toward high achievers and how people react when they fall.

Main ideas

The image is older than the phrase

Herodotus tells of Thrasybulus, tyrant of Miletus, answering a messenger from Periander of Corinth by walking through a wheat field and lopping off every ear that stood above the rest. Livy gives the Roman version: Tarquinius Superbus, asked by his son Sextus what to do at Gabii, silently strikes the heads off the tallest poppies in his garden. In both stories the lesson is political: a ruler keeps power by removing the prominent.

The direction of the cut changed

In the ancient stories, the person at the top does the cutting. In the modern sense, it runs the other way: peers, colleagues and the public resent and pull down whoever rises above them. The phrase kept the poppies and the scythe but moved the scythe into the crowd's hands.

An Australian and New Zealand label

“Tall poppy” became everyday vocabulary in Australia during the Depression, when New South Wales Premier Jack Lang's plan to cut the highest public-sector salaries was described as cutting down the tall poppies. From there it came to mean any prominent achiever, and “tall poppy syndrome” the national habit, real or supposed, of resenting them.

Each culture has its own name

Aksel Sandemose's 1933 novel A Fugitive Crosses His Tracks set out the Law of Jante, ten rules for a small Danish town that all come down to “don't think you're anyone special.” Japanese has the proverb that the nail that sticks out gets hammered down. In the Philippines and elsewhere, crab mentality describes crabs in a bucket pulling back any one that tries to climb out.

Deservingness decides the reaction

Australian psychologist Norman Feather studied attitudes toward tall poppies from the late 1980s onward. His finding was not simple envy. People were pleased by the fall of high achievers when they saw the success as undeserved or the person as arrogant, and much less pleased when the success seemed earned and the person modest. The resentment follows a judgment about fairness.

Online, everyone is visible at once

A feed puts strangers' wins, launches, salaries and holidays in front of millions of people who did not ask to see them. Success that once stayed within a town or an office now reaches a crowd large enough that some part of it will always want to cut it down. A viral post about a new job or a funding round can draw a pile-on within hours.

Critique

  • It can shield the powerful from criticism. Calling criticism “tall poppy syndrome” turns any objection to a rich or famous person into envy. A complaint about a billionaire's conduct or a celebrity's behavior can be dismissed without being answered, which is exactly the kind of move a fallacy guide warns about.
  • Egalitarianism is not only envy. The habit of deflating self-importance can also be read as a defense of social equality: a refusal to defer to status, wealth or titles. Many Australians and Scandinavians describe their version as a virtue, not a syndrome.
  • National stereotypes rest on thin evidence. Claims that one country cuts down its tall poppies more than another are mostly anecdotal. Feather's cross-cultural work found the reactions he measured in several countries, and found them tied to perceived fairness more than to nationality.
  • Surveys of victims measure perception. Workplace surveys report that many high achievers, often women, say they have been undermined for their success. These reports matter, but they record how people experienced events, not whether envy caused them.

Impact

The phrase now turns up whenever a successful person draws a wave of criticism online, and in management and career writing about why high performers hide their achievements at work. It sits close to the main character of the day, the person a platform singles out each day for a pile-on, and to dogpiling, the mechanics of that pile-on. It also inverts impostor syndrome: one is the fear that success is undeserved, the other is the crowd deciding that it is.

How to read this page. An editorial summary for orientation. It separates the ancient political anecdote from the modern social phrase, and the research finding (people react to whether success seems deserved) from the popular claim (people simply envy success). Companion in the series: Impostor syndrome.