← Philosophy

The Hedonic Treadmill

Luncheon of the Boating Party, Pierre-Auguste Renoir
Luncheon of the Boating Party, Pierre-Auguste Renoir

A reader's summary of the idea that people quickly get used to good fortune and drift back to where they started: where the phrase came from, the lottery-winners study that made it famous, how later research qualified it, why it keeps coming up in every online argument about money and happiness, and what it does and does not imply about trying to be happier.

The idea at a glance

The hedonic treadmill, also called hedonic adaptation, is the tendency of people to return to a fairly stable level of happiness after positive or negative changes in their lives. Gains in income, possessions or status bring a lift that fades as the new situation becomes normal, and expectations rise to meet it. The image is of a runner on a treadmill: however hard they run, they stay in the same place. It is a close relative of negativity bias, since losses relative to the new baseline sting more than further gains please, and it is part of the background to FOMO and to the steady upward drift of what counts as enough.

Origin

The phrase comes from the psychologists Philip Brickman and Donald Campbell, in their 1971 chapter “Hedonic Relativism and Planning the Good Society”, published in a volume on adaptation-level theory edited by M. H. Appley. Adaptation-level theory, developed by Harry Helson, held that people judge any stimulus, a weight, a temperature, a brightness, against a neutral point set by their recent experience. Brickman and Campbell applied the same logic to satisfaction with life and drew an uncomfortable conclusion for policy: if people adapt to every improvement, raising the general standard of living might not make anyone lastingly happier.

The idea is much older than the name. Epicurus and the Stoics warned that desires expand to meet what they are given, and Seneca advised rehearsing the loss of comforts so as not to take them for granted. Arthur Schopenhauer, in The World as Will and Representation (1818), described life as swinging like a pendulum between pain, when a desire is unmet, and boredom, once it is satisfied. Adam Smith's remark that the mind returns, sooner or later, to its natural and usual state of tranquillity after any change of fortune is often cited as an early statement of the same pattern.

History and context

The study that made the idea famous came in 1978. Brickman, Dan Coates and Ronnie Janoff-Bulman published “Lottery Winners and Accident Victims: Is Happiness Relative?” in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. They interviewed a small group of Illinois lottery winners, a matched control group and a group of people recently paralysed in accidents. The winners were not significantly happier than the controls and reported taking less pleasure in ordinary activities such as talking with a friend or eating breakfast. The accident victims were less happy than the others, but less unhappy than most people would predict. The study is small and its samples are modest, but its headline, that winning the lottery does not make you much happier, became one of the most repeated findings in popular psychology.

A few years earlier the economist Richard Easterlin had reported what became known as the Easterlin paradox (1974): within a country, richer people tend to be happier, yet as countries grew richer over decades, average reported happiness barely rose. Adaptation and rising expectations were among the leading explanations, alongside the idea that people care about their income relative to others'. In 2006 Ed Diener, Richard Lucas and Christie Napa Scollon published “Beyond the Hedonic Treadmill” in the American Psychologist, which kept the core idea but revised it: baseline levels are usually mildly positive rather than neutral, they differ between people, they can shift, and some life events leave lasting changes. Longitudinal data from large German and British household panels, analysed by Lucas and colleagues, showed that on average people did not fully recover from long unemployment, the death of a spouse or serious disability.

Main ideas

Good news wears off

People react strongly to a change in their circumstances and then, over weeks or months, drift back toward their usual level of satisfaction. The pay rise becomes the salary; the new car becomes the car. What we notice is the change, not the level.

So does much bad news

Adaptation runs in both directions. People who suffer setbacks often recover more of their wellbeing than they, or onlookers, predicted. This is the hopeful half of the idea, and the half the online version usually leaves out.

Expectations rise with attainment

Each gain resets the reference point. Once a comfort is normal it stops registering as a pleasure and starts registering as a baseline, so its loss would hurt while its presence barely pleases. Running faster keeps you in the same place.

Adaptation is not complete

Later research found that some events, such as long unemployment, widowhood or severe disability, leave lasting marks on average, and that individuals differ widely. The treadmill is a strong tendency, not a law that returns everyone to the same point.

Not everything adapts equally

Things that keep changing, keep demanding attention or are shared with others, such as relationships, varied experiences and absorbing work, seem to resist adaptation better than fixed possessions that fade into the background.

In the feed

Online, the hedonic treadmill is mostly invoked in three places. The first is personal finance, where it is the standard warning about lifestyle creep: each raise is absorbed by a bigger flat, a better car and pricier habits, until the higher income feels exactly as tight as the lower one did. Frugality and early-retirement communities treat stepping off the treadmill as the whole point, and it sits close to the self-aware spending trends of loud budgeting and doom spending. The second is the recurring “does money buy happiness?” thread, which usually cites a famous number. Daniel Kahneman and Angus Deaton reported in 2010 that day-to-day emotional wellbeing in the United States stopped rising at around $75,000 a year; Matthew Killingsworth found in 2021 that it kept rising. In 2023 the two sides ran an adversarial collaboration and concluded that happiness keeps rising with income for most people, with a plateau only for the least happy minority. The nuance rarely survives the repost.

The third place is the feed itself. Social media resets reference points constantly, because what people compare themselves with is no longer the neighbour's house but the most enviable life among millions. Designers of engagement products know the same mechanism from the other side: the Hook model relies on variable rewards precisely because a predictable reward is quickly adapted to, and the endless novelty of doomscrolling is in part a way of outrunning adaptation one post at a time. The popular language of “dopamine” and “dopamine detoxes” is often a loose, neuroscience-flavoured restatement of the treadmill.

Critique

  • The famous study is small. The 1978 paper compared a few dozen people at one point in time, without measuring them before their windfall or accident. It shows that the gap between winners and others was smaller than expected, not that each winner returned to a prior level.
  • Adaptation is partial and uneven. Large panel studies show that some losses leave lasting effects on average and that people differ a great deal. Treating the treadmill as complete can make serious hardship sound trivial.
  • It can become an excuse for inaction. Brickman and Campbell's worry, that improving conditions might not raise happiness, is easily turned into an argument against improving them. Health, security and freedom from poverty matter whether or not they show up as a lasting rise in reported mood.
  • Measurement shapes the result. Life satisfaction, day-to-day emotion and a sense of meaning do not move together. Income, for instance, is more strongly tied to how people evaluate their lives than to how they feel hour by hour, so claims about whether money “buys happiness” depend on which question was asked.
  • The popular formulas oversimplify. The widely shared claim that happiness is 50 percent genes, 10 percent circumstances and 40 percent deliberate activity, from a 2005 paper by Sonja Lyubomirsky, Kennon Sheldon and David Schkade, was later criticised by researchers, including the authors themselves, as a misleading reading of variance statistics.

What it suggests

Researchers who study adaptation, notably Sheldon and Lyubomirsky in their work on how to slow it, point to a few consistent patterns. Gains that bring continued variety and attention, such as new skills, experiences or relationships, fade more slowly than one-off purchases. Appreciation, the deliberate act of noticing what has become normal, counteracts the reset, which is the modern form of Seneca's advice. And because expectations rise with every gain, how a change compares with what one expected can matter as much as the change itself. None of this abolishes the treadmill; it is a way of walking on it more deliberately.

Impact

The hedonic treadmill changed how psychologists and economists think about wellbeing. It is one reason measures of life satisfaction now sit beside GDP in debates about progress, as discussed in critiques of GDP, and one reason the vibecession is not as puzzling as it first looks: people judge their circumstances against a reference point that has already moved. For a reader, the useful habit is to separate the two halves of the idea. Good things fade faster than we expect, which is a reason to be sceptical of the next purchase. Bad things often fade faster too, which is a reason to be less afraid of the next setback.

How to read this page. A reader's summary for orientation, not a psychological review. Dates, titles and attributions, especially the details of the 1971 chapter, the design and findings of the 1978 study, the income figures in the Kahneman–Deaton and Killingsworth papers, and the older philosophical quotations, should be checked against the primary sources before being quoted.